Selecting The Best Manufacturing Destination: A Comparative Analysis Of China, Vietnam, And India
China, Vietnam, and India are popular choices for businesses when it comes to sourcing and manufacturing goods. However, deciding on the best manufacturing destination can be a complex process that depends on various factors such as the type of goods being produced, location, skilled labor, cost of production, and infrastructure and logistics.
1. CATEGORIES OF GOODS
The type of goods being produced can greatly influence the choice of manufacturing destination.
China is known for producing high-tech goods such as electronics and machinery. According to a report by the World Bank, in 2019, China accounted for 28% of global high-tech exports, making it the world's leading producer of high-tech goods.
In contrast, Vietnam is known for textiles, footwear, and furniture, with the textile industry being the largest contributor to Vietnam's exports.
India has a strong presence in the pharmaceutical and automotive industries, with the Indian pharmaceutical industry being the third-largest in the world by volume.
Buyers looking to manufacture high-tech products may find China to be the best option, while those looking for textiles, furniture, and pharmaceuticals may find Vietnam and India to be more suitable.
2. LOCATIONS OF MANUFACTURERS
The location of manufacturers can greatly impact the cost of production and transportation.
China has a well-developed coastal manufacturing base, with cities such as Shanghai and Shenzhen being major manufacturing hubs. These cities have access to seaports, making it easier to import and export goods. However, labor costs are higher in coastal cities, while inland regions offer lower costs but less developed infrastructure.
In contrast, Vietnam and India have more dispersed manufacturing bases, with factories located across the country. This can make transportation and logistics more challenging but can also offer lower costs in certain areas.
Buyers looking for cost-effective manufacturing options may find Vietnam and India to be more suitable, while those looking for a well-developed manufacturing base may find China to be the best option.
3. SKILLED LABOR
The availability of skilled labor is important for the success of manufacturing operations.
China has a large pool of skilled workers, especially in the high-tech industries, but labor costs are higher than in Vietnam and India.
India has a large pool of technically skilled workers, especially in the information technology and pharmaceutical industries.
Vietnam is still developing its skilled labor force, but it has made significant progress in recent years, especially in the textile and electronics industries.
4. COST OF PRODUCTION AND LABOR
Cost is a significant factor for businesses when choosing a manufacturing destination.
According to a report by Boston Consulting Group, the average labor cost per hour in China in 2020 was $6.5, while in India it was $3.5 and in Vietnam, it was $3. This makes Vietnam and India more cost-effective for labor-intensive industries.
In addition, China's cost of production has been increasing in recent years due to rising labor and material costs, making Vietnam and India more attractive options for businesses looking to reduce production costs.
Buyers looking for cost-effective manufacturing options may find Vietnam and India to be more suitable, while those willing to pay higher labor costs for a more developed manufacturing base may find China to be the best option.
5. QUALITY OF INFRASTRUCTURE AND LOGISTICS
China has a well-developed infrastructure and transportation network, which includes an extensive system of highways, railways, ports, and airports. The country has invested heavily in its transportation infrastructure, making it easier to move goods across the country.
As a result, according to the World Economic Forum's Global Competitiveness Report 2021, China ranks 12th in the world for overall infrastructure, India ranks 58th, and Vietnam ranks 67th. India and Vietnam are still developing their infrastructure, which can lead to challenges in transportation and logistics.
When considering logistics, it's worth noting that China has a highly developed logistics industry, with a variety of options for freight transport and warehousing. In contrast, Vietnam and India have less developed logistics industries, with limited options for transport and storage.
We are driven to provide our clients with the tools to succeed. Our expertise in the region and our industry know-how allow our clients to make the right decision by building innovative product ranges from reliable suppliers across Asia!
Learn more about our Procurement Outsourcing Services
Check out our LinkedIn